Best to worst:
Hard Candy Glamoflauge, $4, WalMart
covers dark circles but application is a bit thick.comes in three shades, and I picked "light." *what I'm currently using*
Sonia Kashuk, $12, Target
Have to rub the product to make it blendable. Good coverage. You are given a palette to match to your skin tone. I always used the "light concealer." My dark circles didn't require the neutralizer or the setting powder, as I have my own separate powder for that.
Revlon Concealer/Highlighter **not pictured**, $7, any drugstore
No coverage. Highlighter didn't highlight at all. Do not buy!